Bait and Switch — Pedigree of a Yarn: Billie Sol Estes, John Liggett, Nigel Turner, and the Laws

J. KEVEN HOFELING, ESQ.

JFK ASSASSINATION RESEARCH • SCHOLARS AND RESEARCHERS GROUP WORK PRODUCT

Salt Lake City, Utah · j.keven.jd@jkhofelinglaw.org · https://jkhofelinglaw.org/

— A SERIES IN FIVE PARTS — PART II OF V —

IN DEFENSE OF THE REPUTATION OF DAVID W. MANTIK, M.D., PH.D., AND IN REFUTATION OF THE JFK “BODY SWITCH” THEORIES

THE INTERVIEW: 63 YEARS LATER: DR. DAVID MANTIK & ROBERT MORNINGSTAR ON JFK FORENSIC FRAUD & “THE MEASURE OF EVIL” · TIMESTAMPED TRANSCRIPT

Bait and Switch

Part II — Pedigree of a Yarn: Billie Sol Estes, John Liggett, Nigel Turner, and the Lawsuit

THIS SERIES

Part I — What Dr. Mantik Said, and What Robert Morningstar Told the World He Said
The November 12 interview as it was actually recorded; the two emails that re-labeled it a “MJ-13 Global UFO Webinar” and a “JFK–Tippit Body Switch” program; the ninety-three seconds in which Morningstar baited his guest with Tippit and the guest declined the bait; and a direct word to Dr. Mantik and Christopher Mantik about what is being done with their names.

Part II — Pedigree of a Yarn: Billie Sol Estes, John Liggett, Nigel Turner, and the Lawsuit (this installment)
Where the “body double” story actually came from: a convicted swindler’s 2003 memoir, a 2003 television segment built on it, the federal lawsuit and six-figure settlement that followed, and the way the tale mutated into Morningstar’s named-Tippit version and, later, Dr. Fetzer’s nameless “Major.”

Part III — Tippit Was Never Available: The Custody Record, the Rose Autopsy, and the “Resemblance”
A minute-by-minute custody record for Officer Tippit’s body from Tenth Street to Laurel Land; three brains compared—the President’s as the Parkland and Bethesda witnesses saw it, the substitute brain Douglas Horne exposed, and Tippit’s as Dr. Earl Rose dissected it—which disposes of the “Tippit brain” claim; the open casket and the thousand policemen who filed past; and six photographs that end the “striking resemblance” talk.

Part IV — The “Major,” the Two Morgues, and Rick Russo’s Second Body
Dr. Fetzer’s alternative candidate examined in its strongest form; what Rivera’s two-point overlay actually does and why it cannot exclude anyone; what every bone in a man’s head being broken does to a face; the ears; the HSCA anthropologists’ findings; the old-morgue/new-morgue research, which is serious and must be distinguished from the body-switch claims grafted onto it; and Rick Russo’s case for a second body, tested pillar by pillar.

Part V — Dr. Fetzer’s Ten Lines of “Proof,” Answered — and What the Body-Switch Theories Cost Us
Each of the ten propositions tested against the numbered photographs, the sworn testimony and the documents; the “Major” who has no name, no unit and no death certificate; the men who handled the President’s body; questions for Mr. Morningstar, Dr. Fetzer and Mr. Russo; and why the research community cannot afford to carry this baggage into the sixty-fourth year.

Summary of Part II. A claim’s pedigree is evidence of its worth, and the body-switch story has the pedigree of a tabloid. Its mortician, John Liggett, enters the record in October–November 2003 through two outlets at once: the memoir of Billie Sol Estes—the convicted Texas swindler and LBJ bagman whose own trial judge heard him say he lived in a dream world—written with French journalist William Reymond, and Nigel Turner’s ninth installment of The Men Who Killed Kennedy, which put Liggett’s ex-wife on camera. In Estes’s telling the body was an anonymous lookalike; the television segment named no double at all. The History Channel was sued by Liggett’s brother for falsely tying him to the plot, settled in 2005, and agreed to broadcast his denial. Officer Tippit is nowhere in that stream. His name was grafted onto it by Robert Morningstar, who says he conceived the “Tippit brain” theory in 1992–94 and the X-ray-and-photograph swap in 1996–98, and who in 2015 braided his Tippit story into the Estes–Liggett tale—Tippit’s body flown out of Love Field, Liggett altering it aboard a plane. Dr. Fetzer rejects Tippit and the braid, but in 2017–18 supplied a third variant: a nameless “Major” identified by nothing but a photographic overlay; and Rick Russo, building on genuinely important research into Bethesda’s two morgues, proposes that the Fox photographs show an unnamed body instead of that of President Kennedy photographed at the Naval Medical Research Institute. Three versions, three different corpses (four, if Mr. Russo’s unnamed agent is distinguished from Dr. Fetzer’s Major), one shared feature—none has ever produced a document, a witness to a transfer, or a name. The nickname that gave the Tippit version its plausibility was put to three Dallas officers by Morningstar’s own early collaborator, Greg Burnham, and every one of them denied it. In its newest form, circulated on November 15 but not yet published, Dr. Fetzer’s branch no longer claims to prove a substitution—only that the photographs alone cannot rule one out. Part II lays the lineage out so that Parts III through V can test each branch on its own evidence.

I · Why the Pedigree Matters

In a courtroom the provenance of a story is not a side issue. A witness who first told his tale forty years after the event, for money, after a prior conviction for fraud, is impeached before he finishes his first sentence—not because late, paid, convicted witnesses are always wrong, but because the fact-finder is entitled to know where a story came from before deciding how much of it is credible. The body-switch theories have been passed around the research community for twenty years as though they were part of the medical-evidence record. They are not. They came from somewhere, and where they came from is the first thing a careful reader should know.

There are, as I will show, not one but three distinct body-switch stories in circulation, with three different corpses in them. Their advocates borrow one another’s credibility—the Tippit meme cites Liggett, Morningstar cites Estes, Dr. Fetzer cites Rivera, and all of them cite Lifton and Horne, who proposed nothing of the kind. Untangling the braid is the only way to test any strand of it.

II · Stream One: The Estes–Liggett Story (2003–2005)

John Melvin Liggett was a Dallas embalmer with a reputation for reconstructive work who died in 1975, shot while trying to escape custody after his arrest for the attempted murder of a woman named Dorothy Peck. He entered the assassination literature twenty-eight years after his death, and he entered it through Billie Sol Estes.

Estes needs little introduction. He was the West Texas “wheeler-dealer” whose fertilizer-tank and cotton-allotment frauds sent him to federal prison twice and whose ties to Lyndon Johnson made him, in later life, a conduit for ever-larger claims about the assassination—first that he knew the identities of the shooters, then that he knew who ordered the killing of Henry Marshall, and finally, in his seventies, that he knew what had been done to the President’s body. His assassination story was first published in French in October 2003 as JFK: le dernier témoin (Flammarion), written with the journalist William Reymond, and then in English in his self-published 2005 memoir Billie Sol Estes: A Texas Legend. Reymond himself later described the English book as a first draft that he and a co-writer had prepared (Lobster, no. 65).

Vasilios Vazakas, reviewing the case against Johnson for Kennedys and King in 2012, summarized the relevant passage of the 2005 book (pp. 155–157): Estes, having adopted “a mutated form of David Lifton’s body alteration theory,” said that the alteration was not performed on Kennedy but on a lookalike; that a mortician named John Liggett had been tasked before the assassination with finding a body resembling the President’s; that on November 22 Liggett was picked up in a hearse carrying the lookalike, boarded a plane at Love Field, and made the double appear to have been shot from behind; and that photographs of both bodies were later “mixed and matched for the official story.” Vazakas’s verdict—“Who can believe such a man? Or such a story?”—was accompanied by the reminder that Estes had told the court at his second fraud trial that his trouble was that he lived in a dream world (Vazakas, “Evaluating the Case Against Lyndon Johnson”, citing the Wall Street Journal, August 7, 1979).

Note what is not in Estes’s story. There is no J. D. Tippit. The double is an unnamed corpse procured in advance. There is no brain switch. There is no X-ray switch. The entire Tippit apparatus that Morningstar’s emails now carry was added later, by Morningstar.

The same month the French book appeared, Nigel Turner’s The Men Who Killed Kennedy returned to the History Channel with three new hours, and the first of them, “The Smoking Guns,” gave seventeen minutes to John Liggett (series history, Mary Ferrell Foundation; the segment). Turner’s witnesses were Liggett’s former wife Lois, her daughter, and a Restland co-worker. Their account—summarized at the time by Kevin Fong and reposted on this Forum (#354176)—was that Liggett was called away from a family funeral on November 22, said he had to go to Parkland, returned a day later disheveled, hurried the family to Austin, San Antonio and Corpus Christi, relaxed when Ruby shot Oswald (“Everything’s OK now”), and came into money afterward. Nowhere in the broadcast does anyone say whose body Liggett worked on, and nowhere does anyone say Tippit.

EXHIBIT F — THE TELEVISED LIGGETT STORY — “THE MEN WHO KILLED KENNEDY: THE SMOKING GUNS” (HISTORY CHANNEL, NOVEMBER 2003)
EXHIBIT F — The Men Who Killed Kennedy series historyThe Mary Ferrell Foundation’s history of Nigel Turner’s series: two hours in 1988, three more in 1991, a sixth in 1995, and the final three added by the History Channel in November 2003. The Liggett material is in the 2003 installment “The Smoking Guns,” linked from the image at the 26:39 mark. Turner had already been burned once, in 1991, by the Christian David/“Corsican hitmen” story; the Liggett segment would cost his network a settlement.

Dave Perry, who investigated the segment at the time, laid out its sourcing problems in “The Reinvention of John Liggett”: three on-camera witnesses who “seem to know something,” and no documentary proof of any of it. Jim DiEugenio, whose sources inside the research community are as good as anyone’s, wrote on this Forum in 2017 that “the whole John Liggett story is a pile of baloney,” that “my sources say that Billy Sol Estes had a role in beginning it,” and that Turner “was never a good guy for our side” (#356692; see also “Lois Liggett: Challenge to Jim DiEugenio”).

III · The Lawsuit and the Settlement

The segment did not merely tell a story about a dead embalmer. It showed a photograph it said was Liggett’s brother Malcolm with Jack Ruby at the Carousel Club, and it had Lois Liggett say that Malcolm met John in a Corpus Christi motel two days after the assassination. Malcolm Liggett, a retired labor economist and court mediator living in Vero Beach, Florida, said he was in Santa Barbara at the time, that the man in the photograph was not him, and that the program had made him “the link that brings together Jack Ruby and John Liggett.” In July 2004 he sued A&E Television Networks in federal court for defamation and invasion of privacy (James Kirley, “Vero Beach man sues A&E Networks over JFK program,” July 6, 2004). In March 2005 the network settled. The monetary terms were confidential; DiEugenio has since disclosed that the payment was in six figures (Forum thread). The History Channel agreed to broadcast a statement “communicating Liggett’s denial of involvement in the cover-up alleged in the documentary,” and its spokeswoman confirmed that “the matter was resolved to the parties’ mutual satisfaction” (Grace Murphy, Sun-Sentinel, March 19, 2005).

I will be careful about what the settlement proves. A settlement is not a judicial finding that the Liggett story is false; it is a network’s decision that it could not defend the story at trial. But that decision, by a defendant with every incentive and resource to defend it, is a fact about the story’s evidentiary footing, and it is a fact the body-switch advocates never mention when they cite “the Liggett episode of The Men Who Killed Kennedy” as though it were a documentary record. Consider what the network would have had to prove: that a Dallas embalmer reconstructed a presidential lookalike aboard an aircraft on the afternoon of November 22, 1963. It had three family recollections and a photograph of the wrong man. It paid.

IV · Stream Two: Morningstar Grafts Tippit onto the Tale (1992–2015)

Robert Morningstar did not get the Tippit story from Estes or from Turner; by his own account he had it first. In the editor’s note to his 2015 UFO Digest piece “The JFK–Tippit Brain/Body Switch”, he dates his research to 1992–1999, describes presentations at the Third Decade symposia in 1992–93, says that in 1993 he found that Tippit “so closely resembled” Kennedy that fellow officers teased him as “Jack” and “JFK,” that in 1994 he concluded Tippit’s brain had been swapped for the President’s so that a single bullet through the brain could be blamed for both deaths, and that between 1996 and 1998 he concluded that Tippit’s X-rays and doctored photographs had been substituted for Kennedy’s. The same chronology appears in his 2017 article “The Ultimate Secret of the JFK Assassination” and in a 2011 republication, “Who Is Really Buried in Arlington?” His November 14, 2026 email to the Group moves the starting point back a notch:

“I received a complete copy of Gary Murr’s manuscript in 1992… That’s what gave me the key to the Tippit–JFK Brain/Photo/X-Ray Body Swap.”

Two observations. First, Gary Murr’s manuscript is a study of the Tippit shooting—the witnesses, the shells, the timing on Tenth Street. It is catalogued at Baylor’s Poage Library (“Tippitt Shooting, Nov. 22, 1963 — Gary Murr”). Nothing in its description concerns a body switch, and in thirty-four years Morningstar has never quoted a page of it that does. Whatever “key” he found in it was his own. Second, and more important, the 2015 article is where the two streams are braided. In it the Estes–Liggett lookalike becomes Tippit: Tippit is killed “about 40 minutes after JFK so his body could replace Kennedy’s,” his body is moved from Methodist Hospital to Parkland “under guise of autopsy” by Dr. Earl Rose, and then to Love Field and “Air Force 2,” where John Liggett alters it. Estes never said Tippit. Turner never said Tippit. Morningstar supplied the name, and then borrowed their mortician to carry the body.

There is a third observation, and it comes from inside the circle. Greg Burnham, publisher of AssassinationofJohnFKennedy.com and a founding member of the JFK Research Assassination Forum, worked closely with Morningstar when Morningstar first began investigating Tippit as a body double, and pursued the angle with him enthusiastically. Within a month or two he had put the resemblance and the nickname to Dallas police officers he interviewed personally: Detective J. Harrison of the Criminal Intelligence Section, Officer Gerald Lynn Hill, and motorcycle officer Bobby Hargis, who rode just behind and to the left of the presidential limousine in Dealey Plaza. He took care not to tell them what he was investigating. He mentioned the claim almost in passing—“I heard that Tippit looked just like JFK and that his nickname among other DPD personnel was, in fact, ‘JFK’”—so as not to color their answers. Every one of them denied it, and two laughed at the nickname. Harrison, as Burnham paraphrases him, described Tippit as “lanky, all arms and legs,” and thin compared with a President who had filled out in his forties. Burnham told Morningstar that he could not continue (Greg Burnham, email to the author, November 15, 2026, circulated to the Group). The nickname that Morningstar’s chronology dates to 1993 was tested by his own collaborator against the men who knew Tippit intimately, and it failed.

EXHIBIT G — THE MAN HIS FELLOW OFFICERS KNEW — SIX PHOTOGRAPHS OF J. D. TIPPIT
EXHIBIT G — Six photographs of J. D. Tippit across his lifeSix photographs of J. D. Tippit, from his youth to the Dallas Police Department portrait used in the “JFK Body Switch” meme. This is the man the Dallas officers Greg Burnham interviewed had worked beside: a long, narrow face, deep-set eyes under a heavy brow, a high hairline, prominent ears and a lean build—“lanky, all arms and legs,” as Burnham paraphrases Detective Harrison. None of them saw John F. Kennedy in him, and every one of them denied that he had been called “JFK.” Part III sets these photographs beside the President’s.

The graft has consequences that Part III will exploit. Estes’s lookalike was procured in advance—a corpse with no family, no police department, no medical examiner and no funeral. Tippit had all four. By choosing a named Dallas police officer whose body was autopsied by the county medical examiner at 3:15 that afternoon, photographed on the morgue table with a case number on his chest, embalmed at Dudley Hughes, viewed in an open casket under police guard, and buried on November 25 before a thousand of his fellow officers, Morningstar chose the one candidate in Texas whose whereabouts that weekend can be documented minute by minute.

V · Stream Three: The NMRI Photographs and a Nameless Second Body — Dr. Fetzer and Rick Russo (2017–2026)

Dr. James Fetzer rejects the Tippit identification outright. “Definitely NOT J.D. Tippit,” he wrote to me on June 12, 2026. “I have Tippit’s autopsy photos and, despite Robert’s enthusiasm, neither of the bodies at Bethesda was his.” In an addendum on June 20 he added, for “those holding out for J.D. Tippit as the body double,” that “the Earl Rose autopsy photos dispel it,” and that Tippit “does not (remotely) resemble the phony JFK.” On that much he and I agree, and I will hold him to it.

But Dr. Fetzer has a double of his own. In his June 11 email he wrote that “the Groden [bootleg autopsy] photos are not of JFK but of another body, presumably that of ‘The Major’, who arrived in a casket that Dennis David was ordered not to log in,” that he had “called this out in 2017 and in presentations in Portland and Seattle in 2018” (cosmicconvergence.org), and—after I pointed out that Dennis David has always said he never saw inside that casket—that he had never claimed otherwise: “We have the remains of a man with no name, no unit, no death certificate, and no missing-serviceman report, which makes him PERFECT for the role of body double.” His proof is Larry Rivera’s overlay of a living left-profile portrait of the President onto the left-profile autopsy photograph, published at pages 325–326 of JFK: 21st Century Revelations, together with Rick Russo’s ear comparison and a list of ten “lines of proof” that he set out on June 17 and has since published at State of the Nation (June 24, 2026). Parts IV and V of this series will answer that case in full.

The most developed form of this stream is not yet in print. In a draft dated October 15, 2026, titled “When Official Records Contradict Themselves: A Forensic–Evidentiary Analysis of the JFK Autopsy Photographs,” Dr. Fetzer recasts the Major in the language of the Federal Rules of Evidence. The Author’s Note says that Microsoft Copilot helped locate precedents and draft and manage the citations. The draft credits Mr. Russo’s interviews for the two morgues and adds a NAMRI laboratory “suitable” for a clandestine post-mortem procedure. It now says, citing only Dr. Fetzer’s own June 2026 article, that Dennis David was told not to log in a casket holding a body “identified only as ‘the Major.’” And it lays out a three-place timeline: the President in the old morgue at 6:35 p.m. for alteration of the wounds, the President in the new morgue at 8:00 p.m. for the official autopsy, and the Major at NAMRI “undergoing a parallel autopsy.” But the claim has also changed in strength. In June the NAMRI setting was, for Dr. Fetzer, prima facie proof of another body. In October, “Whether Fetzer’s conjecture is ultimately correct is not the point”; the point is only that substitution “cannot be ruled out by reference to the photographs themselves.” On November 15, after Part I of this series appeared, Dr. Fetzer circulated the draft to Dr. Mantik and his family, to Mr. Morley, Mr. Horne and more than a dozen others. He described it as having “nothing to do with Tippit but everything to do with ‘the Major,’” said it had been submitted for publication but not yet accepted, and invited comment and criticism of what he now calls “our ‘body double’ theory,” his, Mr. Rivera’s and Mr. Russo’s. Part IV, §VIII, examines the draft in full.

Dr. Fetzer’s variant has a close cousin, and it deserves to be identified precisely because it grows out of serious research. Rick Russo (not to be confused with the author Gus Russo), the Bethesda autopsy researcher and co-producer of JFK: The Enduring Secret, who convened the surviving Bethesda men in Pittsburgh in 1992 and has spent more time with them than almost anyone, set out his view in a March 24, 2024 program with William Matson Law (“The Mystery of Bethesda”). Its foundation is the discovery—real, and important—that Bethesda had an old morgue in Building 2 as well as the new morgue in Building 8, and that the background of the Fox photographs (a metal stirrup headrest, distinctive floor tile, a wall telephone) matches nothing the Bethesda men saw in either, but resembles the animal morgue at the Naval Medical Research Institute (NMRI) behind the hospital. On that foundation Mr. Russo builds a second story: that the Fox photographs were taken at NMRI of “this other body altogether,” possibly the body of a dead Secret Service agent that James Fox is said to have been sent to collect, so that “we don’t even have one photograph of President Kennedy in the public domain” (at 1:21:59). Mr. Russo calls this speculation, and says so on the program; Mr. Law, beside him, said he would need “cold hard fact” before believing in two bodies (at 1:32:50). Anthony Venturella, whose “Chasing the Darkness” thread on the Education Forum is the fullest statement of the two-morgue chronology, likewise raises a second body only as a possibility—a “second option” that “may have been picked up at NMRI” (#589289). Part IV separates the two-morgue research, which I take seriously, from the second-body inference, which I do not, and tests the latter on its own evidence.

VI · Three Stories, Three Corpses, No Evidence of a Transfer

Estes–Liggett (2003–05) Morningstar (1992–2026) Fetzer–Rivera / Russo (2017–26)
Who is the double? An anonymous lookalike procured in advance. Officer J. D. Tippit. Fetzer: an unnamed “Major” whose casket Dennis David was told not to log. Russo: an unnamed body, possibly a Secret Service agent’s, photographed at NMRI.
What was switched? The body, altered aboard a plane; photographs of both bodies “mixed and matched.” Tippit’s brain (1994), then his X-rays and photographs (1996–98), then—by 2015—his body, via Liggett. Only the photographs; the President’s body was at Bethesda, the substitute at NMRI being photographed.
Source of the identification A twice-convicted swindler, forty years on, for a book. Morningstar’s reading of a 1996 split-face composite and a nickname. A two-point photographic overlay (Rivera); an ear comparison against a Fort Worth photograph (Russo).
Who says they saw the transfer? No one. Liggett died in 1975; the witnesses describe his moods. No one. Rose, Hughes, the DPD escort and a thousand mourners say the opposite. No one. Dennis David did not see the casket’s contents; no one has ever named the Major or the agent.
Documentary record of the substitute None. Complete—and it places Tippit in Dallas, autopsied, embalmed and buried. None: no name, no unit, no death certificate, no morgue log, no missing-serviceman report.
What the other advocates say DiEugenio: “a pile of baloney.” Network settled rather than defend it. Fetzer: “Definitely NOT J.D. Tippit”; Rose’s photos “dispel it.” Morningstar: it was Tippit. Josephs: the Fox photographs show the President, taken early in another room; the ear-anchored overlays line up. Law: “I need cold hard fact.”
EXHIBIT G — THE BRAIDED LINEAGE OF THE BODY-SWITCH STORY, 1992–2026
EXHIBIT G — Lineage chart of the four body-switch candidates, 1992 to 2026A lineage chart of the four candidates described above: the Estes–Liggett lookalike (2003–05), Morningstar’s Officer Tippit (1992–2026), Dr. Fetzer’s nameless “Major” (2017–26), and Mr. Russo’s unnamed second body (1992–2024). The chart shows where each story borrowed from another and where one advocate rejected another’s candidate. Each item is sourced in the text.

The three stories are not corroborating accounts of one event. They are three incompatible accounts of three different corpses, each of whose advocates disbelieves the other two. Morningstar’s Tippit is excluded by Dr. Fetzer; Dr. Fetzer’s Major is excluded by Morningstar’s insistence on Tippit; Estes’s advance-procured lookalike is excluded by both, since neither Tippit nor a Major was procured in advance. What they share is a method: start from a genuine anomaly in the medical record—the Parkland–Bethesda wound discrepancies, the fraudulent brain report, the altered X-rays, the missing photographs, the two caskets—and resolve it by positing a second body for which there is no independent evidence at all. It is the method of the epicycle. Every anomaly Dr. Mantik and Douglas Horne have documented is fully explained by what the record shows was done to John F. Kennedy’s own body and to the record of it. The second corpse adds nothing but a liability.

If any of the advocates publishes a revised statement of his theory while this series is running, I will answer anything new in it in a postscript.

VII · A Note on the 1967 Reinterment

The Facebook post Morningstar circulated closes with the suggestion that the President’s March 1967 reinterment at Arlington was “the moment JFK’s actual remains were finally placed inside his casket, replacing J.D. Tippit’s body.” The reinterment is thoroughly documented: the temporary gravesite of November 1963 drew up to three thousand visitors an hour and more than sixteen million in three years, a permanent site was built a few yards away beginning in 1965 (Arlington National Cemetery, “President John F. Kennedy Gravesite”), and on the evening of March 14, 1967, after the cemetery had closed, the President’s casket and the remains of his two deceased infant children were moved to it in the presence of Senators Robert and Edward Kennedy and Cardinal Cushing, with Mrs. Kennedy and President Johnson attending the consecration at seven the next morning (History.com; The Press, March 17, 1967). The casket was moved sealed; no account of the evening has it opened. Nothing about a documented, publicly attended move of a sealed casket is evidence of what was inside it in 1963, and the post offers nothing beyond the coincidence that the move occurred. I mention it only because it shows the trajectory of this material: every new teller adds an episode, and no teller adds a document or testimony.

Part III leaves the storytellers and goes to the record. It follows Officer Tippit’s body from the pavement on Tenth Street to the grave at Laurel Land, hour by hour and witness by witness; it sets the brain Dr. Earl Rose dissected beside both the President’s own brain, as the Parkland and Bethesda witnesses saw it, and the substitute brain of the Bethesda supplementary report, and lets the record dispose of the “Tippit brain”; and it sets six photographs of J. D. Tippit beside the man he is said to have resembled.

Respectfully submitted to Drs. David and Christopher Mantik, to the silent readers of this thread, to all members of the Forum, and to the JFK Assassination Scholars and Researchers Group,

J. Keven Hofeling, Esq. (Retired)
Salt Lake City, Utah · Monday, November 16, 2026

PART II OF V • BAIT AND SWITCH • NEXT: PART III — TIPPIT WAS NEVER AVAILABLE

Formatting, renders and infographics produced with AI assistance; every quotation, count, measurement and citation was reviewed and verified by the author, who is responsible for the accuracy of all research and content.

—

NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIALITY

____
https://educationforum.ipbhost.com/topic/32438-bait-and-switch-%E2%80%94-in-defense-of-the-reputation-of-dr-david-w-mantik-and-a-refutation-of-the-jfk-%E2%80%9Cbody-switch%E2%80%9D-theories-%E2%80%94-a-series-in-five-parts/#findComment-607322

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.