| J. KEVEN HOFELING, ESQ.
JFK ASSASSINATION RESEARCH • SCHOLARS AND RESEARCHERS GROUP WORK PRODUCT Salt Lake City, Utah · j.keven.jd@jkhofelinglaw.org · https://jkhofelinglaw.org/ — A SERIES IN FIVE PARTS — A SIXTH INTERLUDE BEFORE PART V — IN DEFENSE OF THE REPUTATION OF DAVID W. MANTIK, M.D., PH.D., AND IN REFUTATION OF THE JFK “BODY SWITCH” THEORIES THE INTERVIEW: 63 YEARS LATER: DR. DAVID MANTIK & ROBERT MORNINGSTAR ON JFK FORENSIC FRAUD & “THE MEASURE OF EVIL” · TIMESTAMPED TRANSCRIPT Bait and Switch A Sixth Interlude — Did Dr. Fetzer Read It? The “Authentication” Gambit, the Pretzel Logic of the Major, and Thirty-One Questions Still Waiting
I said in the Fifth Interlude (#607492) that personal accusations would no longer set the order of publication. This Interlude is not a reply to accusations. It answers the substance of Dr. Fetzer’s two responses, which I have posted in the thread in full, with his exhibits (#607593, #607594), and it records his conduct toward the questions he has been asked. Part V follows. I · Did He Read It?At 6:52 a.m. on November 19, before Part IV(A) appeared, Dr. Fetzer wrote to the Group that “we should be talking about my case for ‘the Major,’” and that I wanted instead to talk about anything else. That afternoon Part IV(A) was posted (#607511). It examined his case for the Major in its strongest form: Rivera’s overlay at pages 325–326, the NAMRI headrest, the morphology of a fractured face, the HSCA anthropologists, the ears, the provenance of the photographs, and his own unpublished brief, quoted and answered section by section. Part IV(B) followed the next day (#607567). His responses came within hours of each. Here is what they do not contain.
Two Parts of nearly 19,000 words produced two responses that quote neither. When a reply attacks a position the author never took and skips the sections that answer it, the reader is entitled to ask the question in this Interlude’s title. Dr. Fetzer, did you read Parts IV(A) and IV(B) before you answered them? If so, quote the sentence in either Part in which I argued that the autopsy photographs are authentic. II · The Seven Claims, and the Answer to EachStripped of repetition, the two responses make seven claims. Each is answered in one line, and then more fully in the sections that follow.
III · The “Authentication” GambitDr. Fetzer writes that the “threshold question is whether the surviving photographic record satisfies the foundational requirements necessary to support reliable identification in the first place,” and that I have not shown that it does. I agree that it does not, and Part IV(A) said why: the camera test, the sealed letter, Knudsen, Spencer, Stringer’s brain film, the missing views, and my own memorandum on the admissibility of evidence suspected of fraud. On that record a court would exclude the photographs and X-rays as proof of the wounds under Rules 403 and 1003 after a hearing under Rule 104(a), and admit them only to prove the fraud (Rule 105). We are not arguing about whether the photographs pass authentication. We agree that they do not. We are arguing about what follows, and on that point Dr. Fetzer has nothing to say. What follows is fatal to the Major. Every item of evidence Dr. Fetzer has offered for a second body—Rivera’s overlays, the ears, the nose and lips viewed from the right, the hair part viewed from the left, the “Stare of Death,” the headrest, the skull flap that comes and goes—is taken from the autopsy photographs, and most of it from bootleg copies of them several generations removed. If, as he insists, those photographs cannot establish identity because they are unauthenticated, then by the same rule they cannot establish non-identity. A rule that excludes the photographs excludes the overlays made from them. He applies the rule to every photograph that shows the President and exempts every copy that he reads as showing someone else. That is special pleading (IEP, “Fallacies”), and it is the whole of his case. What follows is the hierarchy, and the hierarchy is unanimous. When fraudulent evidence is excluded, the law does not open the field to the most interesting hypothesis. It falls back on the best remaining evidence: the records made at the time and the sworn testimony of the people who saw the body (Part IV(A), Exhibit AD). Those witnesses—the Parkland physicians and nurses, the Bethesda technicians, the FBI agents, the photographer, the mortician, the honor guard—describe one body, and it is the President’s. Dr. Fetzer has not produced one witness, in sixty-three years, who saw a second body on the morgue table and said so. The burden. Dr. Fetzer writes that “the burden rests not upon critics to establish every aspect of a competing hypothesis, but upon defenders of the photographic record.” I am not defending the photographic record; I have spent two Parts impeaching it. But the deeper error is in the logic. Showing that evidence is unreliable removes it. It does not turn its absence into evidence for something else. The proposition that a named or nameless Major lay on that table is a positive claim of fact, and in history, in law and in science the burden of a positive claim rests on the one who asserts it. To say “the photographs are not authenticated, therefore the Major remains in play” is an argument from ignorance (SEP, “Fallacies”). The impossible standard. His recurring question is whether the record has been authenticated “sufficiently to exclude alternative explanations.” No evidence of any kind meets that standard, because an alternative explanation can always be invented. A rule under which nothing can ever be excluded is not a rule of evidence. It is a guarantee that the hypothesis will never be tested. Mr. Drago’s phrase for interpretations built this way, in his November 18 email to the Group, is “non-falsifiable,” and it is exact (§IV). IV · Pretzel LogicThe circularity charge, turned around. Dr. Fetzer says that Part IV(B) argues in a circle, because it reasons from the altered throat in the photographs to the conclusion that the photographs show the President. That is not the argument. The identification of the throat rests on witnesses. Stringer, who took the photographs, was shown them under oath and said the wound looked “about the same” as it did that night and that they were taken “before anything was done” (Part IV(B), Exhibit AF). Perry, shown the photograph, did not say it was not the President; he said it was not what he had done to the President. Crenshaw said it was Perry’s incision, mutilated (Part IV(B), Exhibit AP). Dr. Fetzer lists four ways to authenticate a photograph: chain of custody, witness identification, forensic comparison and provenance. Part IV supplied witness identification (Stringer, Perry, Crenshaw), forensic comparison (the anthropologists) and as much provenance as the government left us. His statement that these foundations are ones “which we do not have—and which Hofeling does not provide” is not a disagreement with Part IV. It is a description of a document he did not read. Now look at his own Section X, which he renumbered on November 18 as his arguments eight through eleven. It says that Humes altered the throat wound “as it appears in the autopsy photographs,” and that Crenshaw’s diagrams and Perry’s statements prove the throat was altered after Parkland. That argument uses the autopsy photographs to prove what was done to the President’s throat. In his response to Part IV(B) he then asks of the same photographs: “But is the body itself that of President Kennedy?” He cannot use the photographs to prove that the President’s throat was altered and then deny that they show the President. If they show the President, they do not show the Major. If they do not, his arguments eight through eleven prove nothing. That is the circle, and it is his alone. Conceding the explanation, keeping the anomaly. In his response to Part IV(B) Dr. Fetzer “readily” accepts that the President’s body was at Bethesda, that there were three casket entries, and that clandestine surgery occurred before the autopsy. He also accepts, in his response to Part IV(A), that Robinson and another technician saw Humes enlarge the head wound with a saw. Those are the facts that produce the anomalies on his list: the head that differs from Parkland, the skull flap present in one view and absent in another, the throat that is no longer a tracheotomy, the room that is not the morgue of record. Having conceded the cause, he still counts the effect as evidence for a second body. That is double counting. Once an anomaly is explained by what was done to the President, it has no weight left to give to the Major. The rescue that sinks the ship. His expanded response of November 21 adds a new argument: that I assume, “without explanation,” that a substitute body “would have remained unaltered in every respect material to his comparison.” I assume nothing of the kind. I pointed out what the hypothesis requires. But consider what his answer means. Every feature of the body that matches the President—Perry’s incision, the wounds the witnesses describe, the ear and nasal tip the anthropologists matched—must now have been surgically manufactured on the Major. Every feature that does not match is proof of the Major. A hypothesis that treats a match as alteration and a mismatch as substitution cannot be refuted by any observation. Karl Popper called that the mark of a theory that has stopped being science (SEP, “Karl Popper”). Dr. Fetzer, a philosopher of science, knows this better than I do. And it is unnecessary. If the conspirators could alter the Major to look like the President, they could alter the President—which is exactly what Dr. Fetzer now concedes they did. The Major is an entity whose only function is to explain what the conceded surgery already explains. Ockham’s razor removes him (IEP, “William of Ockham”). The equivocation on “authentic.” On November 19 Dr. Fetzer wrote to the Group that Dr. Mantik “has demonstrated that the JFK autopsy X-rays are not authentic or original,” and that his own research shows “the same is true of the JFK autopsy photographs: none of them is authentic or original, because their subject is not the body of John Fitzgerald Kennedy.” That sentence uses one word in two senses. Dr. Mantik’s finding is that the X-rays are altered copies of the President’s X-rays—forgeries of his record, not pictures of another man. “Not authentic” in Dr. Mantik’s sense means altered. In Dr. Fetzer’s sense it means a different person. Sliding from one to the other is how the Major is attached to Dr. Mantik’s name. V · The AnthropologistsDr. Fetzer writes that I “repeatedly” invoke the HSCA anthropologists as resolving identification, and that conclusions drawn from a disputed corpus “cannot independently authenticate it,” indicating at most “anatomical similarities.” The anthropologists occupy one section of Part IV(A), and they were not asked to authenticate anything. Authentication asks whether an item is what it purports to be. Identification asks who is depicted. Dr. Clyde Snow and Dr. Ellis Kerley were asked the second question, and they answered it with the method Dr. Fetzer himself lists as an authenticating foundation: forensic comparison. They measured ten facial indices on autopsy photograph 29 and two living photographs, found the deviations that posture, gravity and massive cranial trauma produce, and then compared eight autopsy views with forty-three photographs of the President, finding “no inconsistencies” in the eyes, nose, mouth or ears and identical traits in the nasal septum, the Kennedy nasal tip and the architecture of the ear (Part IV(A), Exhibit Y; HSCA Vol. VII, pp. 48–49). I do not defend the House Select Committee. Its conduct was indefensible in documented respects: it told the public that the Bethesda witnesses refuted the Parkland doctors when its sealed files showed the opposite (Part IV(B), Exhibit AM), and it sealed its own experts’ finding that the Navy camera could not have taken the autopsy photographs. But misconduct must be proved act by act, from documents. There is no evidence in the released record of misconduct in the anthropologists’ identification, and Dr. Fetzer offers none. He does not challenge one measurement, one index, one trait or one sentence on page 48. To reject their work because the Committee misbehaved elsewhere is the genetic fallacy (IEP) : it judges a finding by its origin rather than its content. In forty-eight years no body-switch advocate has published an answer to that page. The responses to Part IV(A) and IV(B) are the latest to decline. VI · The Anomaly List, Item by ItemDr. Fetzer’s response to Part IV(A) lists twelve anomalies, lettered (a) through (l). Here they are, with the answer to each and where Part IV gave it.
On the overlays he asks: “Which specific anatomical differences identified in Rivera’s overlays are explained by which documented fractures?” That question reverses the burden a second time. The proponent of a forensic method must show that it is reliable—tested, with a known error rate and accepted standards—before its result means anything (Rule 702; Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, 509 U.S. 579 (1993)). Rivera has offered a grid and the phrase “child’s play.” When David Josephs anchored the same images on the ear they lined up. A method that gives opposite answers depending on where one places the pin has no error rate to speak of, and no opponent is obliged to map its every discrepancy to a fracture. On Robinson he writes that “a witness cannot be treated as reliable when his testimony supports one conclusion and disregarded when it supports another.” I agree, and I invite him to apply it. Robinson spent the night rebuilding the President’s head. Nothing in his HSCA interview or his Review Board interview suggests the body was anyone else’s. He described a right-temple puncture, a large occipital defect, a face that could be viewed and a body that could have lain in an open casket (MD 180). It is Dr. Fetzer who takes Robinson’s skull flap and leaves Robinson’s identification behind. On the family he repeats that “Jackie and Bobby reportedly did not recognize the body.” The Second Interlude (#607437) set out, page by page, what Manchester actually wrote. Question 11, which asks for the page on which Robert Kennedy says the words attributed to him, has been asked since November 18. The answer is still “reportedly.” Mr. Drago described the move precisely in his November 18 email to the Group: [G]rief-driven reactions to the mortician’s work are “interpreted as accusations and ultimately proofs of body substitutions.” VII · The Fallacy LedgerThe moves below are named in the standard references (SEP; IEP) and, where they apply, in Table 2 of the Field Manual’s Postscript (#603344). The Manual’s first principle stands: the move is labeled, not the man, and sincere believers make these moves as readily as anyone (#602404; #602947).
VIII · Thirty-One Questions, and the Discourtesy of SilenceA scholar who demands a formal public apology, a point-by-point response from Dr. Mantik and an answer to his eleven arguments owes the same courtesy in return. Since November 16 Dr. Fetzer has been asked fourteen questions in the First, Third and Fourth Interludes, ten more in the Fifth, and seven more below. In that time he has written thousands of words to the Group—on Sandy Hook, on Drago, on the Nobel Prize, on my motives and on authentication—and has answered one question: Tippit is now “unlikely.” The Field Manual’s rule for a citation that goes unanswered is to number it, re-post it unchanged, and let the count accumulate (#603344, move 1). The count before this Interlude stands at twenty-four asked, one answered, two answered in part, and twenty-one ignored. Seven more are added below. That is not a difference of opinion. It is a refusal to engage, and it is disrespectful to every reader who has followed this thread in good faith.
Seven new questions arise from the responses themselves.
IX · What This Costs Dr. Mantik, Horne, Lifton and Law—and the CaseDr. Fetzer writes that the very idea he would undermine Dr. Mantik’s research is “completely ridiculous,” and cites a Nobel nomination letter he drafted in June. I do not question his admiration. I question the effect of his conduct, which is measurable. The Major’s brief was mailed on November 15 to Dr. Mantik, Christopher Mantik and Rachel Mantik and fifteen others. Since then Dr. Mantik has been called upon again and again, in emails copied to the Group and beyond, to “affirm (or deny)” the Major’s arguments, as though his life’s work on the X-rays were answerable for a body no one can name. His findings—the 6.5 mm object and the white patch on the X-rays, the copy films, the stereo test of the back-of-head photographs—are evidence of forgery of the President’s record that would stand in any courtroom. Every time they are carried onto a mailing list in the same envelope as the Major, a defender of the official story is handed the easiest rebuttal there is: guilt by association. Dr. Fetzer’s November 19 email to the Group did not help. In it he wrote, “Yes, of course, I am a holocaust denier, a Sandy Hook skeptic,” and listed 9/11 and the moon landing among his subjects. Readers can judge his tone for themselves. A skeptic who meets the Major in that company will not stay to read about optical density. The cost does not stop with Dr. Mantik. Douglas Horne spent three years at the Review Board and the years since documenting the three casket entries and the surgery on the President’s head; Dr. Fetzer now “readily” accepts that work and repurposes it as anomalies for a Major that Horne has never endorsed. David Lifton’s thesis was that the President’s own wounds were altered; Dr. Fetzer and Mr. Morningstar enlist him as a forerunner of the body double, and question 13 has gone unanswered for that reason. William Law has interviewed the Bethesda witnesses for more than twenty years and recorded their accounts in In the Eye of History; on Mr. Russo’s own program he said that to believe in another body he would need “cold hard fact, not just speculation” (IV(B), §VII). Every one of those witnesses describes the President. The body-switch theories do not build on that work. They make it irrelevant, because if the photographs show a stranger, the witnesses were describing a body no one photographed. The heaviest cost falls on the newcomer. A researcher who arrives at this case in good faith has a finite number of hours. The documentary case for conspiracy and for clandestine surgery on the President’s body—Boyajian’s report, the Sibert–O’Neill report, Reed, Robinson, Jenkins, Perry, Crenshaw, the Kester letter, the X-ray densitometry—can be mastered and carried into a public argument. The Major cannot, because there is nothing to master: no name, no record, no test. Hours spent on a circus of unnamed bodies and Disneyland doubles are hours taken from the evidence that could still bring the President’s murder to an honest public accounting. Mr. Drago calls the method “absurd” and “non-falsifiable.” His wider characterizations are his own, and I do not adopt them; the Field Manual classifies conduct, not identity. But his description of the method is accurate, and Part IV has now shown why. X · What Would CountIf Dr. Fetzer wants the Major taken seriously, the remedy is in his hands, and it is the same remedy any researcher owes any claim of fact.
Until then, the Major is not a hypothesis in an “early stage of development.” It is a name for the gaps in a record that the government corrupted, and the gaps have already been explained by what the government did to the President’s body. Part V answers the eleven lines of proof one by one. The questions will be carried forward, unchanged and numbered, until they are answered. Respectfully submitted to Dr. Mantik and Christopher Mantik, to Dr. Fetzer, to Mr. Morningstar, to Mr. Drago, to the silent readers of this thread, to all members of the Forum, and to the JFK Assassination Scholars and Researchers Group, J. Keven Hofeling, Esq. (Retired) BAIT AND SWITCH • A SIXTH INTERLUDE • PART V FOLLOWS Formatting, renders and infographics produced with AI assistance; every quotation, count, measurement and citation was reviewed and verified by the author, who is responsible for the accuracy of all research and content. |