{"id":88427,"date":"2026-11-21T15:53:02","date_gmt":"2026-11-21T20:53:02","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/stateofthenation.info\/?p=88427"},"modified":"2026-11-21T15:53:02","modified_gmt":"2026-11-21T20:53:02","slug":"bait-and-switch-in-defense-of-the-reputation-of-david-w-mantik-m-d-ph-d-and-in-refutation-of-the-jfk-body-switch-theories","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/stateofthenation.info\/?p=88427","title":{"rendered":"<h3><b>Bait and Switch:<\/b> IN DEFENSE OF THE REPUTATION OF DAVID W. MANTIK, M.D., PH.D., AND IN REFUTATION OF THE JFK \u201cBODY SWITCH\u201d THEORIES<\/h3>"},"content":{"rendered":"<p><!--more--><\/p>\n<div>\n<div dir=\"ltr\">\n<table width=\"100%\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\">\n<tbody>\n<tr>\n<td><strong>J. KEVEN HOFELING, ESQ.<\/strong><\/p>\n<p><strong>JFK ASSASSINATION RESEARCH \u2022 SCHOLARS AND RESEARCHERS GROUP WORK PRODUCT<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>Salt Lake City, Utah \u00b7 <a href=\"mailto:j.keven.jd@jkhofelinglaw.org\" rel=\"\">j.keven.jd@jkhofelinglaw.org<\/a> \u00b7 <a href=\"https:\/\/jkhofelinglaw.org\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"external nofollow noopener\">https:\/\/jkhofelinglaw.org\/<\/a><\/p>\n<table width=\"100%\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\">\n<tbody>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#7B1E28\" height=\"2\"><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<\/tbody>\n<\/table>\n<p><strong>\u2014 A SERIES IN FIVE PARTS \u2014 A SIXTH INTERLUDE BEFORE PART V \u2014<\/strong><\/p>\n<p><strong>IN DEFENSE OF THE REPUTATION OF DAVID W. MANTIK, M.D., PH.D., AND IN REFUTATION OF THE JFK \u201cBODY SWITCH\u201d THEORIES<\/strong><\/p>\n<p><strong>THE INTERVIEW: <a href=\"https:\/\/rumble.com\/v7ibg12-63-years-later-dr.-david-mantik-and-robert-morningstar-on-jfk-forensic-frau.html\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"external nofollow noopener\">63 YEARS LATER: DR. DAVID MANTIK &amp; ROBERT MORNINGSTAR ON JFK FORENSIC FRAUD &amp; \u201cTHE MEASURE OF EVIL\u201d<\/a> \u00b7 <a href=\"https:\/\/drive.google.com\/file\/d\/1Y84fi8bfvEQgGpn86KAWIuIRbJ9k4ZAp\/view?usp=sharing\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"external nofollow noopener\">TIMESTAMPED TRANSCRIPT<\/a><\/strong><\/p>\n<p><strong>Bait and Switch<\/strong><\/p>\n<p><strong>A Sixth Interlude \u2014 Did Dr. Fetzer Read It? The \u201cAuthentication\u201d Gambit, the Pretzel Logic of the Major, and Thirty-One Questions Still Waiting<\/strong><\/p>\n<table width=\"100%\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\">\n<tbody>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#7B1E28\" width=\"6\"><\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FBF6F6\"><strong>THIS SERIES<\/strong><\/p>\n<div>\n<p><strong>Part I \u2014 What Dr. Mantik Said, and What Robert Morningstar Told the World He Said<\/strong><br \/>\nThe November 12 interview as it was actually recorded; the two emails that re-labeled it a \u201cMJ-13 Global UFO Webinar\u201d and a \u201cJFK\u2013Tippit Body Switch\u201d program; the ninety-three seconds in which Morningstar baited his guest with Tippit and the guest declined the bait; and a direct word to Dr. Mantik and Christopher Mantik about what is being done with their names.<\/p>\n<p><strong>Part II \u2014 Pedigree of a Yarn: Billie Sol Estes, John Liggett, Nigel Turner, and the Lawsuit<\/strong><br \/>\nWhere the \u201cbody double\u201d story actually came from: a convicted swindler\u2019s 2003 memoir, a 2003 television segment built on it, the federal lawsuit and six-figure settlement that followed, and the way the tale mutated into Morningstar\u2019s named-Tippit version and, later, Dr. Fetzer\u2019s nameless \u201cMajor.\u201d<\/p>\n<p><strong>Part III \u2014 Tippit Was Never Available: The Custody Record, the Rose Autopsy, and the \u201cResemblance\u201d<\/strong><br \/>\nA minute-by-minute custody record for Officer Tippit\u2019s body from Tenth Street to Laurel Land; three brains compared\u2014the President\u2019s as the Parkland and Bethesda witnesses saw it, the substitute brain Douglas Horne exposed, and Tippit\u2019s as Dr. Earl Rose dissected it\u2014which disposes of the \u201cTippit brain\u201d claim; the open casket and the thousand policemen who filed past; and Tippit\u2019s morgue photographs beside the President\u2019s autopsy photographs, which end the \u201cstriking resemblance\u201d talk.<\/p>\n<p><strong>Part IV(A) \u2014 The Photographs: The \u201cMajor,\u201d the Overlays, the Ears, and Where the Autopsy Photographs Came From<\/strong><br \/>\nDr. Fetzer\u2019s alternative candidate examined in its strongest form; what Rivera\u2019s two-point overlay does and why it cannot exclude anyone; what every bone in a man\u2019s head being broken does to a face; the HSCA anthropologists\u2019 findings; the Facebook ear meme and the clean comparison that dissolves it; the camera that could not have taken the autopsy photographs, the Knudsen deposition sealed for fifty years, and the missing photographs; and Dr. Fetzer\u2019s legal brief\u2014right that the autopsy materials would not survive a modern evidentiary challenge, wrong about what follows.<\/p>\n<p><strong>Part IV(B) \u2014 The Body: The Two Morgues, the Three Casket Entries, the Throat, and Rick Russo\u2019s Second Body<\/strong><br \/>\nThe old-morgue\/new-morgue research, credited and distinguished; the three Bethesda casket entries at 6:35, 7:17 and 8:00 p.m., with Douglas Horne\u2019s 2025 presentation and the newly found photographs; how the body got there first, by helicopter; the \u201csurgery of the head area\u201d that put David Lifton on the trail, and how Horne refined it; the President\u2019s undamaged face; the desecration of his body; the throat wound over which Dr. Perry was threatened that night and later called a butcher job; Rick Russo\u2019s second body, tested pillar by pillar; and a table tracing each body-switch \u201canomaly\u201d to what actually produced it.<\/p>\n<p><strong>Part V \u2014 Dr. Fetzer\u2019s Eleven Lines of \u201cProof,\u201d Answered \u2014 and What the Body-Switch Theories Cost Us<\/strong><br \/>\nEach of Dr. Fetzer\u2019s propositions tested against the numbered photographs, the sworn testimony and the documents; the \u201cMajor\u201d who has no name, no unit and no death certificate; the men who handled the President\u2019s body; questions for Mr. Morningstar, Dr. Fetzer and Mr. Russo; and why the research community cannot afford to carry this baggage into the sixty-fourth year.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<\/tbody>\n<\/table>\n<table width=\"100%\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\">\n<tbody>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"6\"><\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#EEF1F8\">\n<div><strong>Summary.<\/strong> On November 19 Dr. Fetzer told the Group that we should be talking about his case for the Major. Parts IV(A) and IV(B), some 19,000 words and twenty-five exhibits, did exactly that. His two responses\u2014roughly 3,000 words between them, with an expanded version on November 21\u2014do not quote one sentence of either Part, cite one section, or mention one exhibit by letter.<em> They answer a position I do not hold.<\/em> Their single theme is that the autopsy photographs have not been<em> \u201cauthenticated.\u201d <\/em>Part IV(A) said the same thing at length, in a section titled \u201c<em>Where the Autopsy Photographs Came From\u2014and Why That Is the Real Scandal,\u201d<\/em> and then showed, under the Federal Rules of Evidence, what follows: if the photographs fall, the overlays, the ears, the \u201cnose and lips\u201d and every other piece of the Major fall with them, because they are made from the same photographs. Dr. Fetzer has now conceded in writing that the President\u2019s body was at Bethesda, that there were three casket entries, and that clandestine surgery occurred.<em> Those concessions explain every \u201canomaly\u201d he lists.<\/em> What is left is a hypothesis with no name, no record and no test that could prove it wrong. Meanwhile, of the <u><strong>twenty-four questions<\/strong><\/u> put to him in the Interludes since November 16, he has answered one, <em>and Dr. Mantik is again being publicly told what he \u201cneeds to address.\u201d<\/em> This Interlude reduces the two responses to their seven claims and answers each, then sets out the fallacies, the anomaly list, the cost and the questions.<\/div>\n<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<\/tbody>\n<\/table>\n<p>I said in the <a href=\"https:\/\/educationforum.ipbhost.com\/topic\/32438-bait-and-switch-%E2%80%94-in-defense-of-the-reputation-of-dr-david-w-mantik-and-a-refutation-of-the-jfk-%E2%80%9Cbody-switch%E2%80%9D-theories-%E2%80%94-a-series-in-five-parts\/#findComment-607492\" rel=\"\">Fifth Interlude (#607492)<\/a> that personal accusations would no longer set the order of publication. This Interlude is not a reply to accusations. It answers the substance of Dr. Fetzer\u2019s two responses, which I have posted in the thread in full, with his exhibits (<a href=\"https:\/\/educationforum.ipbhost.com\/topic\/32438-bait-and-switch-%E2%80%94-in-defense-of-the-reputation-of-dr-david-w-mantik-and-a-refutation-of-the-jfk-%E2%80%9Cbody-switch%E2%80%9D-theories-%E2%80%94-a-series-in-five-parts\/#findComment-607593\" rel=\"\">#607593<\/a>, <a href=\"https:\/\/educationforum.ipbhost.com\/topic\/32438-bait-and-switch-%E2%80%94-in-defense-of-the-reputation-of-dr-david-w-mantik-and-a-refutation-of-the-jfk-%E2%80%9Cbody-switch%E2%80%9D-theories-%E2%80%94-a-series-in-five-parts\/#findComment-607594\" rel=\"\">#607594<\/a>), and it records his conduct toward the questions he has been asked. Part V follows.<\/p>\n<h2><strong>I \u00b7 Did He Read It?<\/strong><\/h2>\n<p>At 6:52 a.m. on November 19, before Part IV(A) appeared, Dr. Fetzer wrote to the Group that \u201cwe should be talking about my case for \u2018the Major,\u2019\u201d and that I wanted instead to talk about anything else. That afternoon Part IV(A) was posted (<a href=\"https:\/\/educationforum.ipbhost.com\/topic\/32438-bait-and-switch-%E2%80%94-in-defense-of-the-reputation-of-dr-david-w-mantik-and-a-refutation-of-the-jfk-%E2%80%9Cbody-switch%E2%80%9D-theories-%E2%80%94-a-series-in-five-parts\/#findComment-607511\" rel=\"\">#607511<\/a>). It examined his case for the Major in its strongest form: Rivera\u2019s overlay at pages 325\u2013326, the NAMRI headrest, the morphology of a fractured face, the HSCA anthropologists, the ears, the provenance of the photographs, and his own unpublished brief, quoted and answered section by section. Part IV(B) followed the next day (<a href=\"https:\/\/educationforum.ipbhost.com\/topic\/32438-bait-and-switch-%E2%80%94-in-defense-of-the-reputation-of-dr-david-w-mantik-and-a-refutation-of-the-jfk-%E2%80%9Cbody-switch%E2%80%9D-theories-%E2%80%94-a-series-in-five-parts\/#findComment-607567\" rel=\"\">#607567<\/a>). His responses came within hours of each. Here is what they do not contain.<\/p>\n<table width=\"100%\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\">\n<tbody>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"38%\"><strong>What Part IV said<\/strong><\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"17%\"><strong>Where<\/strong><\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"45%\"><strong>What Dr. Fetzer\u2019s responses say about it<\/strong><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">The photographs cannot be traced to the camera: the HSCA\u2019s experts found the Navy camera could not have taken them, the Kester letter was sealed for fifty years, and the camera disappeared.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\"><a href=\"https:\/\/educationforum.ipbhost.com\/topic\/32438-bait-and-switch-%E2%80%94-in-defense-of-the-reputation-of-dr-david-w-mantik-and-a-refutation-of-the-jfk-%E2%80%9Cbody-switch%E2%80%9D-theories-%E2%80%94-a-series-in-five-parts\/#findComment-607511\" rel=\"\">IV(A)<\/a>, \u00a7VI<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Nothing.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Robert Knudsen\u2019s sealed deposition, his family\u2019s account of missing and altered photographs, Saundra Spencer\u2019s disowning of the prints, Stringer\u2019s brain-film testimony, the missing probe and chest views.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">IV(A), \u00a7VI<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Nothing. He then argues as though Part IV had defended the provenance of the photographs.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">What the Federal Rules would actually do: Rules 901(b)(9), 1003, 1004, 104(a), 403 and 105, spoliation, and the evidentiary hierarchy.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">IV(A), \u00a7VII.C; Exhibit AD<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Nothing. Not one rule is named.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">\u201cIf the photographs fall, the overlays made from them fall with them.\u201d<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">IV(A), \u00a7VII.C<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Nothing. This is the argument that disposes of his case, and it is not mentioned.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">David Josephs anchored the same images on the ear and they lined up.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">IV(A), \u00a7II<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Nothing.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">The anthropologists compared eight autopsy views with forty-three photographs and found identical traits in the ear and the nasal tip.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">IV(A), \u00a7IV; Exhibit Y<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">That they \u201ccannot, standing alone,\u201d authenticate the photographs\u2014<u><em>an answer to a claim I did not make<\/em><\/u> (\u00a7IV below).<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Robinson, under oath to the Review Board, said every bone in the President\u2019s face was broken (MD 180).<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">IV(A), \u00a7III<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">That I am <em>\u201csimply asserting\u201d<\/em> it.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Stringer, shown the throat photographs under oath, said the wound looked \u201cabout the same\u201d as on the night and that they were taken \u201cbefore anything was done.\u201d<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">IV(B), \u00a7\u00a7I, V; Exhibit AF<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">That I offer no \u201cwitness identification.\u201d<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<\/tbody>\n<\/table>\n<p>Two Parts of nearly 19,000 words produced two responses that quote neither. When a reply attacks a position the author never took and skips the sections that answer it, the reader is entitled to ask the question in this Interlude\u2019s title. <em><u><strong>Dr. Fetzer, did you read Parts IV(A) and IV(B) before you answered them?<\/strong><\/u><\/em> If so, quote the sentence in either Part in which I argued that the autopsy photographs are authentic.<\/p>\n<h2><strong>II \u00b7 The Seven Claims, and the Answer to Each<\/strong><\/h2>\n<p>Stripped of repetition, the two responses make seven claims. Each is answered in one line, and then more fully in the sections that follow.<\/p>\n<table width=\"100%\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\">\n<tbody>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"4%\"><strong>#<\/strong><\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"40%\"><strong>Dr. Fetzer\u2019s claim<\/strong><\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"56%\"><strong>The answer<\/strong><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">1<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">The photographs have not been authenticated, so they cannot establish identity.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Agreed that they would not survive authentication\u2014Part IV(A) said so first. It follows that they cannot establish <em>non<\/em>-identity either. His entire case is made of them (\u00a7III).<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">2<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">The burden is on defenders of the official identification.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">The burden is on whoever asserts a fact. He asserts a second body.<em> Removing evidence does not create evidence <\/em>(\u00a7III).<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">3<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Part IV is circular: it uses disputed photographs to authenticate disputed photographs.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\"><u><em>It does not.<\/em><\/u> The identification rests on the witnesses\u2014Stringer, Perry, Crenshaw, the anthropologists\u2014<em>which are three of the four \u201cauthenticating foundations\u201d he lists himself.<\/em> The circular argument is his Section X (\u00a7IV).<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">4<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">If the record is corrupt enough to show fraud, it cannot be reliable enough to show identity.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Fraud in specific views does not make every pixel false; a forged endorsement does not forge the bank. And every alteration documented is an alteration made to disguise <em>the President\u2019s<\/em> wounds (\u00a7IV).<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">5<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">The HSCA anthropologists cannot authenticate the corpus.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">They were not asked to authenticate it. T<em>hey were asked who it shows, and answered with the forensic comparison he says is required<\/em> (\u00a7V).<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">6<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Proof of JFK\u2019s presence is not proof of the Major\u2019s nonexistence.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">No one said it was. Part IV(B) explained every anomaly by what was done to the President\u2019s body\u2014which he now concedes\u2014<em>and showed that the Major has no name, no record and no witness <\/em>(\u00a7IV).<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">7<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Hofeling assumes the substitute body would not have been altered.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\"><em>No such assumption is made.<\/em> His rescue\u2014that the Major was altered to match\u2014makes the hypothesis unfalsifiable and unnecessary (\u00a7IV).<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<\/tbody>\n<\/table>\n<h2><strong>III \u00b7 The \u201cAuthentication\u201d Gambit<\/strong><\/h2>\n<p>Dr. Fetzer writes that the <em>\u201cthreshold question is whether the surviving photographic record satisfies the foundational requirements necessary to support reliable identification in the first place,\u201d<\/em> and that I have not shown that it does. I agree that it does not, and Part IV(A) said why: the camera test, the sealed letter, Knudsen, Spencer, Stringer\u2019s brain film, the missing views, and my own memorandum on<em> the admissibility of evidence suspected of fraud. <\/em>On that record a court would exclude the photographs and X-rays as proof of the wounds under Rules <a href=\"https:\/\/www.law.cornell.edu\/rules\/fre\/rule_403\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"external nofollow noopener\">403<\/a> and <a href=\"https:\/\/www.law.cornell.edu\/rules\/fre\/rule_1003\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"external nofollow noopener\">1003<\/a> after a hearing under <a href=\"https:\/\/www.law.cornell.edu\/rules\/fre\/rule_104\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"external nofollow noopener\">Rule 104(a)<\/a>, and <em>admit them only to prove the fraud<\/em> (<a href=\"https:\/\/www.law.cornell.edu\/rules\/fre\/rule_105\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"external nofollow noopener\">Rule 105<\/a>). We are not arguing about whether the photographs pass authentication. We agree that they do not. We are arguing about what follows, <em>and on that point Dr. Fetzer has nothing to say.<\/em><\/p>\n<p><strong>What follows is fatal to the Major.<\/strong> Every item of evidence Dr. Fetzer has offered for a second body\u2014Rivera\u2019s overlays, the ears, the nose and lips viewed from the right, the hair part viewed from the left, the \u201cStare of Death,\u201d the headrest, the skull flap that comes and goes\u2014is taken from the autopsy photographs, and most of it from bootleg copies of them several generations removed. If, as he insists, those photographs cannot establish identity because they are unauthenticated, then by the same rule they cannot establish non-identity.<em> <u><strong>A rule that excludes the photographs excludes the overlays made from them.<\/strong><\/u><\/em> He applies the rule to every photograph that shows the President and exempts every copy that he reads as showing someone else. <em>That is special pleading (<a href=\"https:\/\/iep.utm.edu\/fallacy\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"external nofollow noopener\">IEP, \u201cFallacies\u201d<\/a>), and it is the whole of his case.<\/em><\/p>\n<p><strong>What follows is the hierarchy, and the hierarchy is unanimous.<\/strong> When fraudulent evidence is excluded, the law does not open the field to the most interesting hypothesis. It falls back on the best remaining evidence: the records made at the time and the sworn testimony of the people who saw the body (Part IV(A), Exhibit AD). Those witnesses\u2014the Parkland physicians and nurses, the Bethesda technicians, the FBI agents, the photographer, the mortician, the honor guard\u2014describe one body, <em>and it is the President\u2019s. <\/em>Dr. Fetzer has not produced one witness, in sixty-three years, who saw a second body on the morgue table and said so.<\/p>\n<p><strong>The burden.<\/strong> Dr. Fetzer writes that <em>\u201cthe burden rests not upon critics to establish every aspect of a competing hypothesis, but upon defenders of the photographic record.\u201d<\/em> I am not defending the photographic record; <u><em>I have spent two Parts impeaching it.<\/em><\/u> But the deeper error is in the logic. Showing that evidence is unreliable removes it. <em>It does not turn its absence into evidence for something else.<\/em> The proposition that a named or nameless Major lay on that table is a positive claim of fact, <em>and in history, in law and in science the burden of a positive claim rests on the one who asserts it. <\/em>To say \u201cthe photographs are not authenticated, therefore the Major remains in play\u201d<u><em> is an argument from ignorance<\/em><\/u> (<a href=\"https:\/\/plato.stanford.edu\/entries\/fallacies\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"external nofollow noopener\">SEP, \u201cFallacies\u201d<\/a>).<\/p>\n<p><strong>The impossible standard.<\/strong> His recurring question is whether the record has been authenticated \u201csufficiently to exclude alternative explanations.\u201d No evidence of any kind meets that standard, <em>because an alternative explanation can always be invented.<\/em> A rule under which nothing can ever be excluded is not a rule of evidence. <u><em>It is a guarantee that the hypothesis will never be tested.<\/em><\/u> Mr. Drago\u2019s phrase for interpretations built this way, in his November 18 email to the Group, is \u201cnon-falsifiable,\u201d and it is exact (\u00a7IV).<\/p>\n<h2><strong>IV \u00b7 Pretzel Logic<\/strong><\/h2>\n<p><strong>The circularity charge, turned around.<\/strong> Dr. Fetzer says that Part IV(B) argues in a circle, because it reasons from the altered throat in the photographs to the conclusion that the photographs show the President. <em>That is not the argument.<\/em> The identification of the throat rests on witnesses. Stringer, who took the photographs, was shown them under oath and said the wound looked \u201cabout the same\u201d as it did that night and that they were taken \u201cbefore anything was done\u201d (Part IV(B), Exhibit AF). Perry, shown the photograph, did not say it was not the President; he said it was not what he had done to the President. Crenshaw said it was Perry\u2019s incision, mutilated (Part IV(B), Exhibit AP). Dr. Fetzer lists four ways to authenticate a photograph: chain of custody, witness identification, forensic comparison and provenance. Part IV supplied witness identification (Stringer, Perry, Crenshaw), forensic comparison (the anthropologists) and as much provenance as the government left us. His statement that these foundations are ones \u201cwhich we do not have\u2014and which Hofeling does not provide\u201d is not a disagreement with Part IV.<em><u> It is a description of a document he did not read.<\/u><\/em><\/p>\n<p>Now look at his own Section X, which he renumbered on November 18 as his arguments eight through eleven. It says that Humes altered the throat wound \u201cas it appears in the autopsy photographs,\u201d and that Crenshaw\u2019s diagrams and Perry\u2019s statements prove the throat was altered after Parkland. That argument uses the autopsy photographs to prove <em>what was done to the President\u2019s throat.<\/em> In his response to Part IV(B) he then asks of the same photographs: <em>\u201cBut is the body itself that of President Kennedy?\u201d<\/em> <u><strong>He cannot use the photographs to prove that the President\u2019s throat was altered and then deny that they show the President.<\/strong><\/u> If they show the President, they do not show the Major. If they do not, his arguments eight through eleven prove nothing.<em> That is the circle, and it is his alone.<\/em><\/p>\n<p><strong>Conceding the explanation, keeping the anomaly.<\/strong> In his response to Part IV(B) Dr. Fetzer \u201creadily\u201d accepts that the President\u2019s body was at Bethesda, that there were three casket entries, and that clandestine surgery occurred before the autopsy. He also accepts, in his response to Part IV(A), that Robinson and another technician saw Humes enlarge the head wound with a saw. Those are the facts that produce the anomalies on his list: the head that differs from Parkland, the skull flap present in one view and absent in another, the throat that is no longer a tracheotomy, the room that is not the morgue of record. Having conceded the cause, he still counts the effect as evidence for a second body. <u>That is double counting<\/u>. <em>Once an anomaly is explained by what was done to the President, it has no weight left to give to the Major.<\/em><\/p>\n<p><strong>The rescue that sinks the ship.<\/strong> His expanded response of November 21 adds a new argument: that I assume, \u201cwithout explanation,\u201d that a substitute body \u201cwould have remained unaltered in every respect material to his comparison.\u201d<em> I assume nothing of the kind.<\/em> I pointed out what the hypothesis requires. But consider what his answer means. Every feature of the body that matches the President\u2014Perry\u2019s incision, the wounds the witnesses describe, the ear and nasal tip the anthropologists matched\u2014<em>must now have been surgically manufactured on the Major<\/em>. Every feature that does not match is proof of the Major. <u><em>A hypothesis that treats a match as alteration and a mismatch as substitution cannot be refuted by any observation.<\/em><\/u> Karl Popper called that the mark of a theory that has stopped being science (<a href=\"https:\/\/plato.stanford.edu\/entries\/popper\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"external nofollow noopener\">SEP, \u201cKarl Popper\u201d<\/a>). Dr. Fetzer, a philosopher of science, knows this better than I do. And it is unnecessary. If the conspirators could alter the Major to look like the President, they could alter the President\u2014<em>which is exactly what Dr. Fetzer now concedes they did.<\/em> The Major is an entity whose only function is to explain what the conceded surgery already explains. <em>Ockham\u2019s razor removes him <\/em>(<a href=\"https:\/\/iep.utm.edu\/ockham\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"external nofollow noopener\">IEP, \u201cWilliam of Ockham\u201d<\/a>).<\/p>\n<p><strong>The equivocation on \u201cauthentic.\u201d<\/strong> On November 19 Dr. Fetzer wrote to the Group that Dr. Mantik \u201chas demonstrated that the JFK autopsy X-rays are not authentic or original,\u201d and that his own research shows \u201cthe same is true of the JFK autopsy photographs: none of them is authentic or original, because their subject is not the body of John Fitzgerald Kennedy.\u201d That sentence uses one word in two senses. Dr. Mantik\u2019s finding is that the X-rays are altered copies of the President\u2019s X-rays\u2014forgeries of his record, <u><em>not pictures of another man.<\/em><\/u> \u201cNot authentic\u201d in Dr. Mantik\u2019s sense means altered. In Dr. Fetzer\u2019s sense it means a different person. <em><u>Sliding from one to the other is how the Major is attached to Dr. Mantik\u2019s name.<\/u><\/em><\/p>\n<h2><strong>V \u00b7 The Anthropologists<\/strong><\/h2>\n<p>Dr. Fetzer writes that I \u201crepeatedly\u201d invoke the HSCA anthropologists as resolving identification, and that conclusions drawn from a disputed corpus \u201ccannot independently authenticate it,\u201d indicating at most \u201canatomical similarities.\u201d <em>The anthropologists occupy one section of Part IV(A), and they were not asked to authenticate anything.<\/em> Authentication asks whether an item is what it purports to be. Identification asks who is depicted. Dr. Clyde Snow and Dr. Ellis Kerley were asked the second question, and they answered it with the method Dr. Fetzer himself lists as an authenticating foundation: <em>forensic comparison.<\/em> They measured ten facial indices on autopsy photograph 29 and two living photographs, found the deviations that posture, gravity and massive cranial trauma produce, and then compared eight autopsy views with forty-three photographs of the President, finding <em>\u201cno inconsistencies\u201d in the eyes, nose, mouth or ears and identical traits in the nasal septum, the Kennedy nasal tip and the architecture of the ear <\/em>(Part IV(A), Exhibit Y; <a href=\"https:\/\/www.aarclibrary.org\/publib\/jfk\/hsca\/reportvols\/vol7\/pdf\/HSCA_Vol7_M4_Authenticity.pdf\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"external nofollow noopener\">HSCA Vol. VII<\/a>, pp. 48\u201349).<\/p>\n<p>I do not defend the House Select Committee. Its conduct was indefensible in documented respects: it told the public that the Bethesda witnesses refuted the Parkland doctors when its sealed files showed the opposite (Part IV(B), Exhibit AM), and it sealed its own experts\u2019 finding that the Navy camera could not have taken the autopsy photographs. But misconduct must be proved act by act, from documents. <u><strong>There is no evidence in the released record of misconduct in the anthropologists\u2019 identification, and Dr. Fetzer offers none.<\/strong><\/u> He does not challenge one measurement, one index, one trait or one sentence on page 48. To reject their work because the Committee misbehaved elsewhere is the genetic fallacy (<a href=\"https:\/\/iep.utm.edu\/fallacy\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"external nofollow noopener\">IEP<\/a>) : it judges a finding by its origin rather than its content.<u><em> In forty-eight years no body-switch advocate has published an answer to that page.<\/em><\/u> The responses to Part IV(A) and IV(B) are the latest to decline.<\/p>\n<h2><strong>VI \u00b7 The Anomaly List, Item by Item<\/strong><\/h2>\n<p>Dr. Fetzer\u2019s response to Part IV(A) lists twelve anomalies, lettered (a) through (l). Here they are, with the answer to each and where Part IV gave it.<\/p>\n<table width=\"100%\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\">\n<tbody>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"7%\"><\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"33%\"><strong>Dr. Fetzer\u2019s anomaly<\/strong><\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"40%\"><strong>What produced it<\/strong><\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"20%\"><strong>Where answered<\/strong><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">(a)<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Back-of-head depictions are hard to reconcile.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Surgery, reconstruction and scalp manipulation of one head\u2014four states of one head\u2014plus manipulated views.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">IV(B), \u00a7\u00a7IV, VII; Exhibits AI, T<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">(b)<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Parkland saw a smaller defect than Bethesda; Robinson and a technician saw Humes enlarge it with a saw.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">He has stated the explanation himself: the President\u2019s wound was enlarged at Bethesda.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">IV(B), \u00a7IV; Exhibit AK<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">(c)<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Crenshaw\u2019s throat drawings versus the \u201cStare of Death.\u201d<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">The President\u2019s throat, cut by Perry and enlarged at Bethesda. He lists \u201ca different body\u201d as one possibility among four, and offers no reason to prefer it.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">IV(B), \u00a7V; Exhibits AO, AP<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">(d), (e)<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">HSCA diagram, Z-374 and Robinson\u2019s skull flap; \u201cone and the same body cannot have a skull flap and not have a skull flap.\u201d<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">It can, at different times: before and after the surgery, and before and after the scalp was rearranged for the after-midnight photographs Horne describes.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">IV(B), \u00a7IV; Exhibit T<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">(f)<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Crenshaw closed the eyes; the eyes are open in the \u201cStare of Death.\u201d<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Eyelids reopen with handling and postmortem change; the protocol records edema and ecchymosis about the left eye, and Robinson describes the facial fractures.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">IV(A), \u00a7III<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">(g), (h)<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">The face does not resemble JFK from the right (nose, lips) or the left (hair part).<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Impressions from degraded copies of a supine, fractured, hyperextended head; the anthropologists\u2019 comparison says otherwise.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">IV(A), \u00a7\u00a7II\u2013V; Exhibits X, Y<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">(i)<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">The metal \u201cstirrup\u201d proves NAMRI; \u201ceven Mr. Hofeling appears to acknowledge\u201d it.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">The headrest is in the photographs; no one disputes it. A room is not a man: a photograph of the President taken during the 6:35\u20138:00 work shows the room where the work was done.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">IV(A), \u00a7VII; IV(B), \u00a7\u00a7I\u2013IV<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">(j)<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Overlays \u201cremain controversial and depend significantly upon methodology.\u201d<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Conceded by him. A method whose result reverses when the anchor point moves cannot exclude anyone.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">IV(A), \u00a7II; Exhibit W<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">(k)<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Tippit is now \u201cunlikely.\u201d<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Credited: question 12 is answered. It took Part III to obtain it.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Part III<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">(l)<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">\u201cMy own conjecture is \u2026 \u2018the Major\u2019 Dennis David was not allowed to log in.\u201d<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">No name, no unit, no death record, no transport, no witness at the table. A conjecture about an unlogged body is not evidence of a body.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Part V<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<\/tbody>\n<\/table>\n<p>On the overlays he asks: \u201cWhich specific anatomical differences identified in Rivera\u2019s overlays are explained by which documented fractures?\u201d <em>That question reverses the burden a second time.<\/em> The proponent of a forensic method must show that it is reliable\u2014tested, with a known error rate and accepted standards\u2014before its result means anything (<a href=\"https:\/\/www.law.cornell.edu\/rules\/fre\/rule_702\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"external nofollow noopener\">Rule 702<\/a>; <a href=\"https:\/\/supreme.justia.com\/cases\/federal\/us\/509\/579\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"external nofollow noopener\"><em>Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals<\/em>, 509 U.S. 579 (1993)<\/a>). Rivera has offered a grid and the phrase \u201cchild\u2019s play.\u201d When David Josephs anchored the same images on the ear they lined up.<em> A method that gives opposite answers depending on where one places the pin has no error rate to speak of, and no opponent is obliged to map its every discrepancy to a fracture.<\/em><\/p>\n<p>On Robinson he writes that \u201ca witness cannot be treated as reliable when his testimony supports one conclusion and disregarded when it supports another.\u201d I agree, and I invite him to apply it. Robinson spent the night rebuilding the President\u2019s head. <u><em>Nothing in his HSCA interview or his Review Board interview suggests the body was anyone else\u2019s.<\/em><\/u> He described a right-temple puncture, a large occipital defect, a face that could be viewed and a body that could have lain in an open casket (<a href=\"https:\/\/www.aarclibrary.org\/publib\/jfk\/arrb\/master_med_set\/pdf\/md180.pdf\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"external nofollow noopener\">MD 180<\/a>).<em> It is Dr. Fetzer who takes Robinson\u2019s skull flap and leaves Robinson\u2019s identification behind.<\/em><\/p>\n<p>On the family he repeats that <em>\u201cJackie and Bobby reportedly did not recognize the body.\u201d<\/em> The <a href=\"https:\/\/educationforum.ipbhost.com\/topic\/32438-bait-and-switch-%E2%80%94-in-defense-of-the-reputation-of-dr-david-w-mantik-and-a-refutation-of-the-jfk-%E2%80%9Cbody-switch%E2%80%9D-theories-%E2%80%94-a-series-in-five-parts\/#findComment-607437\" rel=\"\">Second Interlude (#607437)<\/a> set out, page by page, what Manchester actually wrote. Question 11, which asks for the page on which Robert Kennedy says the words attributed to him, has been asked since November 18. <em>The answer is still \u201creportedly.\u201d <\/em>Mr. Drago described the move precisely in his November 18 email to the Group:<\/p>\n<p>[G]rief-driven reactions to the mortician\u2019s work are <em>\u201cinterpreted as accusations and ultimately proofs of body substitutions.\u201d<\/em><\/p>\n<h2><strong>VII \u00b7 The Fallacy Ledger<\/strong><\/h2>\n<p>The moves below are named in the standard references (<a href=\"https:\/\/plato.stanford.edu\/entries\/fallacies\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"external nofollow noopener\">SEP<\/a>; <a href=\"https:\/\/iep.utm.edu\/fallacy\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"external nofollow noopener\">IEP<\/a>) and, where they apply, in Table 2 of the Field Manual\u2019s Postscript (<a href=\"https:\/\/educationforum.ipbhost.com\/topic\/32263-a-cointelprojtrig-expanded-field-manual-for-the-bona-fide-researcher\/#findComment-603344\" rel=\"\">#603344<\/a>). The Manual\u2019s first principle stands: the move is labeled, not the man, and sincere believers make these moves as readily as anyone (<a href=\"https:\/\/educationforum.ipbhost.com\/topic\/32263-a-cointelprojtrig-expanded-field-manual-for-the-bona-fide-researcher\/#findComment-602404\" rel=\"\">#602404<\/a>; <a href=\"https:\/\/educationforum.ipbhost.com\/topic\/32263-a-cointelprojtrig-expanded-field-manual-for-the-bona-fide-researcher\/#findComment-602947\" rel=\"\">#602947<\/a>).<\/p>\n<table width=\"100%\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\">\n<tbody>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"22%\"><strong>The move<\/strong><\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"40%\"><strong>Dr. Fetzer\u2019s words<\/strong><\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"38%\"><strong>Why it fails<\/strong><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Straw man (Manual move 14)<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">\u201cMr. Hofeling asks readers to accept \u2026 that the identity of the subject can nevertheless be established with confidence\u201d from the photographs.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Part IV(A) argued the photographs would be excluded, and rested identity on the witnesses.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Special pleading<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Unauthenticated photographs cannot establish identity.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">He exempts the same photographs, in bootleg copies, when they are offered against identity.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Argument from ignorance \/ burden shifting<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Alternatives \u201cremain within the legitimate scope\u201d until the record is authenticated.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">The absence of proof for one proposition is not proof of its rival.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Unfalsifiability (ad hoc rescue)<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">The substitute body may have been altered too.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Every match becomes alteration and every mismatch substitution; no observation could count against it.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Double counting<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Accepts the clandestine surgery, then lists its effects as anomalies.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">An explained anomaly has no residual weight.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Equivocation<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">X-rays \u201cnot authentic\u201d (Mantik) and photographs \u201cnot authentic\u201d (the Major).<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Altered copies of the President are not pictures of another man.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Genetic fallacy<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">The anthropologists\u2019 work comes from a disputed corpus and a discredited committee.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">No error in their analysis is identified.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Alice-in-Wonderland logic (move 16)<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">The photographs prove the President\u2019s throat was altered (Section X) but may not show the President.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Both cannot be true.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Firehose (move 9)<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Twelve lettered anomalies and recycled images, most already answered.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Volume is not evidence; each item is answered in \u00a7VI.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Appeal to credentials \/ red herring<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Bugliosi\u2019s praise of <em>Assassination Science<\/em>; a Nobel nomination letter.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Neither addresses a single argument in Part IV.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Motive attribution and DARVO (moves 24, 26)<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">My \u201cmalfeasance,\u201d the \u201cveneer of respectability,\u201d an effort to \u201ccensor and (even) abolish research.\u201d<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Two Parts devoted to examining his hypothesis are not censorship of it. No act of malfeasance is named.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<\/tbody>\n<\/table>\n<h2><strong>VIII \u00b7 Thirty-One Questions, and the<em> Discourtesy of Silence<\/em><\/strong><\/h2>\n<p>A scholar who demands a formal public apology, a point-by-point response from Dr. Mantik and an answer to his eleven arguments owes the same courtesy in return. Since November 16 Dr. Fetzer has been asked fourteen questions in the First, Third and Fourth Interludes, ten more in the Fifth, and seven more below. In that time he has written thousands of words to the Group\u2014on Sandy Hook, on Drago, on the Nobel Prize, on my motives and on authentication\u2014and has answered one question: <em>Tippit is now \u201cunlikely.\u201d<\/em> The Field Manual\u2019s rule for a citation that goes unanswered is to number it, re-post it unchanged, and let the count accumulate (<a href=\"https:\/\/educationforum.ipbhost.com\/topic\/32263-a-cointelprojtrig-expanded-field-manual-for-the-bona-fide-researcher\/#findComment-603344\" rel=\"\">#603344<\/a>, move 1). <u><strong>The count before this Interlude stands at twenty-four asked, one answered, two answered in part, and twenty-one ignored.<\/strong><\/u> Seven more are added below. That is not a difference of opinion. <u><em>It is a refusal to engage, and it is disrespectful to every reader who has followed this thread in good faith.<\/em><\/u><\/p>\n<table width=\"100%\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\">\n<tbody>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"7%\"><strong>#<\/strong><\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"48%\"><strong>The question<\/strong><\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"45%\"><strong>Status after the responses of Nov. 19\u201321<\/strong><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">1<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">What is \u201cunderhanded\u201d? Name the act, actor and evidence\u2014or withdraw the word.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\"><strong>NOT ANSWERED.<\/strong> Now joined by \u201cmalfeasance,\u201d also unparticularized (question 25).<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">2<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Do you adopt or disavow Jim Scott\u2019s accusation that I am an AI-assisted government disinformation agent?<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\"><strong>NOT ANSWERED.<\/strong> Six days.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">3<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Will you stop speaking for Dr. Mantik and ask him privately for his position?<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\"><strong>NOT ANSWERED.<\/strong> On Nov. 19 he wrote again that \u201cDavid needs to address\u201d his arguments.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">4<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Will you add a sentence to your brief stating that Dr. Mantik does not share the Section IX conjecture?<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\"><strong>NOT ANSWERED.<\/strong><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">5<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Will you answer Parts III\u2013V in the thread, point by point?<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\"><strong>IN PART.<\/strong> Responses to IV(A) and IV(B) received and posted; neither is point by point; Part III has never been answered.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">6<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Which word of the sentence for which you demand an apology attacks you rather than a theory?<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\"><strong>NOT ANSWERED.<\/strong><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">7<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Identify a specific occasion on which I got the record wrong, with the citation.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\"><strong>NOT ANSWERED.<\/strong><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">8<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Which criticism of Drago did I \u201csquelch\u201d? Give its date.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\"><strong>NOT ANSWERED.<\/strong><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">9<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">What is the evidence that I am not fair and balanced?<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\"><strong>NOT ANSWERED.<\/strong> Every response you have sent has been forwarded and posted, with your exhibits.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">10<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">How do photographs alleged to show the Major also prove alteration of the President\u2019s throat?<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\"><strong>NOT ANSWERED.<\/strong> See \u00a7IV: the contradiction is now in writing.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">11<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">On what page of Manchester does Robert Kennedy say, \u201cIt doesn\u2019t look like him at all\u201d?<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\"><strong>NOT ANSWERED.<\/strong> Still \u201creportedly.\u201d<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">12<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Is Tippit back in contention?<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\"><strong>ANSWERED.<\/strong> Tippit is \u201cunlikely.\u201d Credited.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">13<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Where does Lifton\u2019s <em>Best Evidence<\/em> propose a body double rather than alteration of Kennedy\u2019s own body?<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\"><strong>NOT ANSWERED.<\/strong><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">14<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Where did I say Mantik denied the evidence you advance, rather than declined your inference?<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\"><strong>NOT ANSWERED.<\/strong><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">15<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Will you correct the statement that I failed to mention your Sandy Hook appeals?<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\"><strong>NOT ANSWERED.<\/strong><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">16\u201319<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">The FEMA document\u2019s provenance; the FBI inference; the excluded evidence; the Supreme Court docket numbers.<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\"><strong>NOT ANSWERED.<\/strong><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">20<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Which numbered photographs show the Major, and which show Kennedy?<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\"><strong>NOT ANSWERED.<\/strong> Now \u201cevery disputed photograph,\u201d none identified.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">21<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">What independently checkable evidence identifies the Major and connects him to NAMRI?<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\"><strong>NOT ANSWERED.<\/strong> Item (l) repeats the unlogged body.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">22<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">For your strongest photographic comparison: sources, provenance, scale, measurements, and what result would count against you?<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\"><strong>IN PART.<\/strong> He concedes the overlays \u201cremain controversial.\u201d No measurements; no falsifying result.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">23<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">Will you join me in rejecting unsupported accusations of agency or concealed affiliation against any participant?<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\"><strong>NOT ANSWERED.<\/strong> Instead he now writes that \u201claunching these personal attacks IS HIS ROLE\u201d of Mr. Drago.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">24<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">Which single item is your strongest affirmative proof of a replacement body?<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\"><strong>NOT ANSWERED.<\/strong> He now says the response \u201cdoes not attempt to prove\u201d the Major.<\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<\/tbody>\n<\/table>\n<p>Seven new questions arise from the responses themselves.<\/p>\n<table width=\"100%\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\">\n<tbody>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"7%\"><strong>#<\/strong><\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" width=\"93%\"><strong>New question<\/strong><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">25<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\"><u><strong>Name the \u201cmalfeasance\u201d: the act, the date and the document\u2014or withdraw the word.<\/strong><\/u><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">26<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\"><u><strong>Quote the sentence in Part IV(A) or IV(B) in which I argued that the autopsy photographs are authentic.<\/strong><\/u><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">27<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\"><u><strong>Where in either response do you address IV(A), \u00a7VI (camera, Kester letter, Knudsen, Spencer, Stringer, missing views) or \u00a7VII.C (the Federal Rules and the hierarchy)?<\/strong><\/u><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">28<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\"><u><strong>If unauthenticated photographs cannot establish identity, by what rule can bootleg copies of the same photographs establish non-identity?<\/strong><\/u><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">29<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\"><u><strong>Your Section X says the throat was altered \u201cas it appears in the autopsy photographs.\u201d Whose throat is it?<\/strong><\/u><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\">30<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#F4F6FB\"><u><strong>Given your premise that the substitute body could have been altered to match, what observation would falsify the Major hypothesis?<\/strong><\/u><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\">31<\/td>\n<td bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\"><u><strong>Which statement on pages 48\u201349 of HSCA Volume VII is wrong, and what is the evidence of misconduct in that analysis?<\/strong><\/u><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<\/tbody>\n<\/table>\n<h2><strong>IX \u00b7 What This Costs Dr. Mantik, Horne, Lifton and Law\u2014and the Case<\/strong><\/h2>\n<p>Dr. Fetzer writes that the very idea he would undermine Dr. Mantik\u2019s research is <em>\u201ccompletely ridiculous,\u201d <\/em>and cites a Nobel nomination letter he drafted in June. I do not question his admiration. I question the effect of his conduct, which is measurable. The Major\u2019s brief was mailed on November 15 to Dr. Mantik, Christopher Mantik and Rachel Mantik and fifteen others. <em>Since then Dr. Mantik has been called upon again and again, in emails copied to the Group and beyond, to \u201caffirm (or deny)\u201d the Major\u2019s arguments, as though his life\u2019s work on the X-rays were answerable for a body no one can name. <\/em>His findings\u2014the 6.5 mm object and the white patch on the X-rays, the copy films, the stereo test of the back-of-head photographs\u2014are evidence of forgery of the President\u2019s record that would stand in any courtroom. Every time they are carried onto a mailing list in the same envelope as the Major, a defender of the official story is handed the easiest rebuttal there is: <em>guilt by association<\/em>. Dr. Fetzer\u2019s November 19 email to the Group did not help. In it he wrote, \u201cYes, of course, I am a holocaust denier, a Sandy Hook skeptic,\u201d and listed 9\/11 and the moon landing among his subjects. Readers can judge his tone for themselves. <em>A skeptic who meets the Major in that company will not stay to read about optical density.<\/em><\/p>\n<p>The cost does not stop with Dr. Mantik. Douglas Horne spent three years at the Review Board and the years since documenting the three casket entries and the surgery on the President\u2019s head; Dr. Fetzer now \u201creadily\u201d accepts that work and repurposes it as anomalies for a Major that Horne has never endorsed. David Lifton\u2019s thesis was that the President\u2019s own wounds were altered; <em>Dr. Fetzer and Mr. Morningstar enlist him as a forerunner of the body double, and question 13 has gone unanswered for that reason.<\/em> William Law has interviewed the Bethesda witnesses for more than twenty years and recorded their accounts in <em>In the Eye of History<\/em>; on Mr. Russo\u2019s own program he said that to believe in another body he would need <em>\u201ccold hard fact, not just speculation\u201d<\/em> (IV(B), \u00a7VII). <u><em>Every one of those witnesses describes the President.<\/em><\/u> The body-switch theories do not build on that work. They make it irrelevant, because if the photographs show a stranger, the witnesses were describing a body no one photographed.<\/p>\n<p>The heaviest cost falls on the newcomer. A researcher who arrives at this case in good faith has a finite number of hours. The documentary case for conspiracy and for clandestine surgery on the President\u2019s body\u2014Boyajian\u2019s report, the Sibert\u2013O\u2019Neill report, Reed, Robinson, Jenkins, Perry, Crenshaw, the Kester letter, the X-ray densitometry\u2014can be mastered and carried into a public argument. T<u>he Major cannot, because there is nothing to master: no name, no record, no test.<\/u> <em>Hours spent on a circus of unnamed bodies and Disneyland doubles are hours taken from the evidence that could still bring the President\u2019s murder to an honest public accounting.<\/em> Mr. Drago calls the method <em>\u201cabsurd\u201d<\/em> and <em>\u201cnon-falsifiable.\u201d<\/em> His wider characterizations are his own, and I do not adopt them; the Field Manual classifies conduct, not identity. But his description of the method is accurate, <em>and Part IV has now shown why.<\/em><\/p>\n<h2><strong>X \u00b7 What Would Count<\/strong><\/h2>\n<p>If Dr. Fetzer wants the Major taken seriously, the remedy is in his hands, <em>and it is the same remedy any researcher owes any claim of fact.<\/em><\/p>\n<ul>\n<li>The Major\u2019s name, rank, unit and date of death, and the record of his death: a casualty report, a death certificate, a mortuary record.<\/li>\n<li>The record of his body\u2019s movement to Bethesda or NAMRI, and the record of its disposition afterward.<\/li>\n<li>The numbered photographs said to show him, and the numbered photographs said to show the President, in one consistent sequence.<\/li>\n<li>For the overlays: the source images and their provenance, the anchor points, the scale and orientation treatment, the measurements, and the result that would have counted against the conclusion.<\/li>\n<li>A witness who saw a body other than the President\u2019s on a table at Bethesda or NAMRI that night, <u><em>and said so.<\/em><\/u><\/li>\n<li><em><u>An answer, in writing, to the thirty-one questions above.<\/u><\/em><\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<p>Until then, the Major is not a hypothesis in an \u201cearly stage of development.\u201d It is a name for the gaps in a record that the government corrupted, and the gaps have already been explained by what the government did to the President\u2019s body. Part V answers the eleven lines of proof one by one. <u><em>The questions will be carried forward, unchanged and numbered, until they are answered.<\/em><\/u><\/p>\n<table width=\"100%\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\">\n<tbody>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#C9A227\" height=\"1\"><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<\/tbody>\n<\/table>\n<p><em>Respectfully submitted to Dr. Mantik and Christopher Mantik, to Dr. Fetzer, to Mr. Morningstar, to Mr. Drago, to the silent readers of this thread, to all members of the Forum, and to the JFK Assassination Scholars and Researchers Group,<\/em><\/p>\n<p><em><strong>J. Keven Hofeling, Esq. (Retired)<\/strong><\/em><br \/>\nSalt Lake City, Utah \u00b7 Saturday, November 21, 2026<\/p>\n<table width=\"100%\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\">\n<tbody>\n<tr>\n<td bgcolor=\"#1F2A5A\" height=\"1\"><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<\/tbody>\n<\/table>\n<p><strong>BAIT AND SWITCH \u2022 A SIXTH INTERLUDE \u2022 PART V FOLLOWS<\/strong><\/p>\n<p><em>Formatting, renders and infographics produced with AI assistance; every quotation, count, measurement and citation was reviewed and verified by the author, who is responsible for the accuracy of all research and content.<\/em><\/td>\n<\/tr>\n<\/tbody>\n<\/table>\n<\/div>\n<\/div>\n<p>____<br \/>\n<a href=\"https:\/\/educationforum.ipbhost.com\/topic\/32438-bait-and-switch-%E2%80%94-in-defense-of-the-reputation-of-dr-david-w-mantik-and-a-refutation-of-the-jfk-%E2%80%9Cbody-switch%E2%80%9D-theories-%E2%80%94-a-series-in-five-parts\/\">https:\/\/educationforum.ipbhost.com\/topic\/32438-bait-and-switch-%E2%80%94-in-defense-of-the-reputation-of-dr-david-w-mantik-and-a-refutation-of-the-jfk-%E2%80%9Cbody-switch%E2%80%9D-theories-%E2%80%94-a-series-in-five-parts\/<\/a><\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[1],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-88427","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-uncategorized"],"jetpack_featured_media_url":"","_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/stateofthenation.info\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/88427","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/stateofthenation.info\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/stateofthenation.info\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/stateofthenation.info\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/stateofthenation.info\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcomments&post=88427"}],"version-history":[{"count":1,"href":"https:\/\/stateofthenation.info\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/88427\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":88428,"href":"https:\/\/stateofthenation.info\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/88427\/revisions\/88428"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/stateofthenation.info\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fmedia&parent=88427"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/stateofthenation.info\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcategories&post=88427"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/stateofthenation.info\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Ftags&post=88427"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}